High-temperature tea and esophageal cancer
We measured tea drinking temperatures of over 50,000 people and followed up with them over a time span of 10 years. In our study, drinking tea at temperatures above 60°C was associated with an increased risk of developing esophageal cancer.
Billions of people start their day by drinking hot beverages, such as tea, coffee, or mate (a commonly used infusion in South America), and many enjoy drinking them throughout the day as well.
However, drinking very hot beverages might not be entirely safe, as earlier studies suggested that people who drink very hot drinks have higher risk of developing esophageal cancer. The previous evidence was limited though, as it was mostly based on perception of tea drinking temperature described by study participants for example as cold, hot, or very hot. Everyone may perceive temperature differently, and we cannot verify exactly how hot is the tea people describe as "hot" or "very hot". No one has ever measured actual beverage drinking temperature among people and assessed whether it influences the future development of esophageal cancer. This is called a prospective study because we assess the risk of disease development in healthy patients.
In a study of over 50,000 patients residing in northeast Iran, we examined the association between the drinking temperature of the tea, and the future risk of developing esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC), which is generally the most common subtype of esophageal cancer. To overcome the limitation of previous studies we recorded the tea temperature both with a thermometer as well as the heat that patients perceived.
Our trained staff interviewed patients in person asking them about a wide range of personal characteristics and potential risk factors of ESCC. We also asked how much tea participants drink, how many minutes they wait between pouring the tea and drinking it, and finally whether they drink tea warm/lukewarm, hot, or very hot.
Furthermore, we measured tea drinking temperature using a method that had shown good reliability in our earlier assessments: two fresh cups of tea were prepared at the time of the interview, one for the participant and the other for the interviewer to measure the temperature using a digital thermometer.
Then, the study participants were followed-up for next 10 years.
Some factors, known as confounding factors, could cause spurious associations in epidemiological studies. For example, if smoking is more common among alcohol drinkers than non-drinkers, simple analysis might show an increased risk of lung cancer associated with alcohol drinking, which may only be related to higher smoking rates among alcohol drinkers rather than the effects of alcohol per se. Here, smoking is a confounding factor for the association between alcohol drinking and lung cancer. We used statistical techniques to control for multiple potential confounding factors, including sex, urban/rural residence, ethnicity, education, wealth, cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption, opium use, and fresh fruit and vegetable consumption.
All measures of higher tea temperature in this analysis (higher measured temperature, reported preference for very hot tea drinking, and shorter time from pouring tea to drinking) were associated with higher ESCC risk. We observed that drinking 700 ml or more of the tea per day at ≥ 60 °C [≥ 140 °F] (compared to less than 700 ml/day at < 60°C) was associated with significantly higher risk of ESCC. Further analysis showed that the observed associations were independent from smoking and alcohol drinking as they persisted among those who never smoked and never drank alcohol.
Taken all together, our results provide strong evidence for an association between drinking beverages at very high temperatures and developing ESCC. However, people could still enjoy their favorite beverages without increasing their cancer risk by drinking them cooler, at < 60°C, which does not appear to increase the risk. More studies are needed on mechanisms of this association and the effects of drinking tea at lower temperatures.
Original Article:F. Islami et al., A prospective study of tea drinking temperature and risk of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma. International Journal of Cancer 0, (2019)
Monika Stankova , Senior Scientific Editor
We thought you might like
Consumed to death: bacteria cause their own extinction by over-polluting the environmentSep 11, 2018 in Microbiology | 2.5 min read by Christoph Ratzke , Jonas Denk
More from Health & Physiology
More than meets the eye: the histones revealed as enzymesJan 12, 2021 in Health & Physiology | 3 min read by Oscar A. Campos , Siavash K. Kurdistani
Understanding how COVID-19 Patients shed viral particles into their environmentJan 4, 2021 in Health & Physiology | 3.5 min read by Joshua L. Santarpia
Mosquito travel diaries: destinations, routes, stowaways, and … costDec 10, 2020 in Health & Physiology | 4 min read by Tovi Lehmann , Ben J. Krajacich , Roy Faiman