Evolution & Behaviour
Algae Living in Salamanders, Friend or foe?
Yellow spotted salamanders are generous hosts to their stressed out green algal guests.
Roughly speaking, our bodies use energy from the sun, but we can't use sunlight directly. Instead, plants and algae collect sunlight and store it as chemical energy through the process of photosynthesis. We can access that fuel directly when we eat plants, or indirectly when we eat other animals that eat plants.
However, in some invertebrate animals (those without a backbone) the relationships to algae are more intimate. Tiny single-celled algal "symbionts" can actually live inside the cells of living corals and small animals like hydra that live in water. The algae live in a safe environment inside animal cells and are provided with building block materials to function. They use sunlight to convert the building block materials into larger molecules to store energy and build cellular structures. At the same time some of that stored solar energy is directly transferred to the host animal, allowing it to live in otherwise nutrient poor environments. Thus the algae and their hosts depend on one another to live and thrive. These mutually beneficial relationships are called photosymbioses.
Photosymbiosis was thought to be absent between algae and vertebrate animals (those with a backbone). One reason for that absence is differences in the immune system between vertebrates and invertebrates. Vertebrate immune systems very specifically recognize invaders and remember them, precluding the long and frequent interactions thought necessary to form a cell-in-cell symbiosis. But there is an exception for that.
The egg fluid of the yellow spotted salamanders is colonized by a microscopic green alga. The relationship was first described by naturalist Henry Orr in 1888. Then, in 2011 it was discovered that the algal cells actually enter the salamander's tissues and sometimes live within the salamander's cells. In a way the algal cell inside salamander cell relationship resembles the interaction of algae and corals, but on the other hand the only known cases of cell-in-cell relations in vertebrates are parasitic infections, like malaria. So how complementary is this salamander-algal interaction?
To understand the salamander-alga relationship, we had to look inside the cells. The variety of RNA molecules (or "expressed genes") in a cell can tell us if a cell is experiencing stress, enacting an immune system response, or undergoing metabolic changes due to some external or internal perturbations. We decided to measure gene expression differences that occur in the alga and the salamander when algae enter salamander cells. This can be done by sequencing (stable) DNA molecules that are reconstructed from (short-lived) RNA molecules of each sample.
Gene expression differences in the algal cells revealed a remarkable response to their new intra-cellular environment. Green algae live off sunlight; making sugars from light, then like us metabolizing them through aerobic respiration. But in low oxygen environments they can also live like yeasts, metabolizing sugars through fermentation. Our experiments showed that algae swimming around in water and in egg fluids use the more common photosynthesis and respiration combination for life. However, algae living inside salamander cells have switched from respiration to fermentation.
In contrast, differences in the salamander RNAs revealed subtle differences from salamander cells that lacked algae. The most striking was the lack of an all-out assault on the algae, as would be expected if the alga was recognized as a pathogen that caused disease. Instead, the salamander cells had what looked like a tuned down immune reaction in response to these entirely foreign algae. It could be that the salamander deliberately recognizes the alga as "friend". But it also could be that the alga tricks the salamander's immune system through some crafty, but unknown mechanisms.
This revelation about the alga's metabolism puts a new twist on the relationship between alga and salamander. It is unlikely to be perfectly analogous to coral-algal photosymbioses because the alga in the salamander is converting sunlight to useable sugar with much lower efficiency. Also fermentation is seen in other cell-in-a-cell relationships in vertebrates, but so far only in parasites, like malaria. At the same time the salamander's tepid immune response has implications for the flexibility of our own immune systems during early development. The algae are entering salamander cells during early development, while the salamander immune system is still learning to differentiate between self and non-self. It is possible that in these salamanders, the alga is becoming recognized as "self" to the salamander.
It is the parallels with beneficial symbionts, such as those found in corals, or parasites, like malaria, that makes the unique relationship between salamander and alga so exciting. Our research has found similarities with both. Future work will further reveal the rules that govern when and how cells coexist in these intimate cell-in-a-cell relationships.
Original Article:J. A. Burns, H. Zhang, E. Hill, E. Kim, R. Kerney, Transcriptome analysis illuminates the nature of the intracellular interaction in a vertebrate-algal symbiosis. eLife 6, e22054 (2017)
Next read: Designer corals shine a bright light on the future of coral reefs by Madeleine JH van Oppen , Patrick Buerger
Dr. Anatoly Kozlov , Senior Scientific Editor
We thought you might like
Symbiogenesis: how algae and bacteria shaped new genes togetherMay 3, 2017 in Evolution & Behaviour | 3.5 min read by Raphaël Méheust , Eric Bapteste
The intimate relationships between seeds and fungiAug 30, 2018 in Plant Biology | 3 min read by Carolina Sarmiento
How did ant-plant interactions evolve?May 3, 2019 in Evolution & Behaviour | 4 min read by Matthew P. Nelsen , Richard H. Ree , Corrie S. Moreau
The Trojan mosquito: an in-house parasite defends against malariaJan 26, 2021 in Health & Physiology | 3 min read by Enock Mukibetti Mararo , Lilian Mbaisi , Edward Makhulu Edmond
More from Evolution & Behaviour
Do our marine highways disrupt blue whale habitats?Mar 1, 2023 in Evolution & Behaviour | 3.5 min read by Luis Bedriñana-Romano
Spring: A Season Of New Beginnings And The End Of The DinosaursFeb 24, 2023 in Evolution & Behaviour | 3.5 min read by Melanie During
Salmon evolve quickly as a response to intense harvesting of their preyFeb 20, 2023 in Evolution & Behaviour | 4 min read by Yann Czorlich
Orb-weaving spiders can hear using their webFeb 10, 2023 in Evolution & Behaviour | 4 min read by Jian Zhou , Junpeng Lai , Ronald Hoy , Ronald Miles
The Mystery of the Lizard TailOct 17, 2022 in Evolution & Behaviour | 3 min read by Navajit S. Baban , Yong-Ak Song